46 pages • 1 hour read
Italo CalvinoA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Part 4 Introduction
Kublai Khan exhibits various moods as he hears Polo’s tales of the cities he visits. On one hand, he accuses Polo of composing “consolatory fables” of invented cities when Khan knows that his empire is declining and rotting (51). Polo replies that if Khan wants to know the extent of the decline, he must also be aware of the happiness in his lands. Sometimes, however, Khan is convinced of the superiority of his empire and accuses Polo of lingering “over inessential melancholies” (52). Polo replies that Khan will never know how to create a truly flourishing empire if he does not learn of the cities that have vanished from memory and of the unhappiness in his lands.
“Cities and Signs 5”
When he comes to the city of Olivia, Polo explains the importance of a city never being “confused with the words that describe it” (53). Thus, were he to describe Olivia’s refinement and splendor, Khan would know from the very same words about the city’s decadence. However, although Polo’s words would be misleading, he paradoxically maintains that “falsehood is never in words; it is in things” (53).
“Thin Cities 4”
The city of Sophronia is composed of two halves. One is essentially a fairground, and the other is a sober marble and cement city which contains institutions like banks, slaughterhouses, and palaces. While one half of the city is permanent, the other is temporary and gets transplanted to other cities. Every year, the sober city is removed so that the fairground Sophronia can stand in its glory.
“Trading Cities 3”
Eutropia is a city composed of several cities, however each of them can only be inhabited in limited intervals. Thus, when a man gets bored of his life in one city, the citizenry moves him on to the next city where everything is different and nothing of his previous life remains. However, it is as though the “city repeats itself” because the inhabitants of different cities engage in the same scenes (56). Thus, paradoxically, of all the cities in the empire Eutropia remains the same.
“Cities and Eyes 2”
Zemrude changes its aspect depending on the beholder’s mood. If they look up, they will know it by its fountains and flapping curtains. However, looking down, they will know it by its gutters. Both versions are true; however, it is easier to go from looking up to looking down than the other way around.
“Cities and Names 1”
Aglaura is a city that is difficult to define. People’s opinions of the city overshadow their ability to experience it as it is. Moreover, previous accounts of what it is like make it impossible to perceive its wonders moment to moment.
“Coda to Part 4”
Khan proposes to describe cities to Polo, who will ascertain from his journeys whether they really exist. He imagines that he has constructed a model city in his mind “from which all possible cities can be deduced” as it contains “everything corresponding to the norm” (64). Polo states that by decreasing the number of abnormal elements, they are more likely to come up with a “probable city” (64). However, there is the risk that one would “achieve cities too probable to be real” (64).
Part 5 Introduction
Khan conjectures that it is better for an empire to “grow within itself” rather than merely from the outside and thus be abundant and flourishing rather than impoverished (65). He contemplates an empire with cities bursting with civilization and dreams of a city with “slender pinnacles, made in such a way that the moon in her journey can rest now on one” (66). Polo names the city of Khan’s dreams as Lalage and says that the pinnacles are so positioned to enable the moon to allow the city to grow eternally. Khan remarks that this growth is happening in lightness.
“Thin Cities 5”
Octavia is “the spider-web city,” a settlement made of threads over a void between two mountains (67). The inhabitants are less insecure than people of other cities because they know that they have limited time; “the net will last only so long” (67).
“Trading Cities 4”
The city of Ersilia is made up of “spider-webs of intricate relationships seeking a form” (68). The inhabitants string color-coded strings between their houses to denote relationships. When the strings become too numerous, the houses are destroyed and the inhabitants leave, so that only the strings and the poles they are suspended from remain. The refugees rebuild Ersilia elsewhere several times. The ruins of the abandoned Ersilias are not dwellings; they are the strings with their networks.
“Cities and Eyes 3”
The city of Baucis is on stilts and hidden from travelers’ eyes under a stratum of clouds that must be climbed by ladders. The inhabitants have everything they need up there and never come down to the ground. People hypothesize variously that Baucis’s inhabitants either hate the earth, respect it too much to make contact with it, or prefer to look at it with telescopes and spyglasses, “contemplating with fascination their own absence” (69).
“Cities and Names 2”
Leandra is a city protected by two species: the Penates which stand at the doors of the houses, and the Lares which stay in the kitchen and belong to the house. The two species stay there as generations of tenants come and go and debate the essence of the Leandra and which of them is more associated with it.
“Cities and the Dead 1”
Melania is a city of never-ending dialogues. Through the passing generations, the dialogue continues, but the protagonists are different: “[T]he participants in the dialogues die one by one and meanwhile those who will take their places are born, some in one role, some in another” (72). As time goes on the roles of the participants differ and the topic of conversation always seems to head for some final denouement, even when the plot appears to thicken.
“Part 5 Coda”
When Marco Polo tells Khan of a bridge’s construction stone by stone, Khan asks which stone supports the bridge. Polo replies that the bridge is supported not by any individual stone but by the arch they form all together. Khan asks why Polo should speak of the stones when only the arch matters. Polo replies that without the stones the arch cannot exist.
Part 6 Introduction
Khan criticizes Polo for never speaking of the city of Venice, the settlement of canals that he longs to hear about. Polo replies that “every time I describe a city I am saying something about Venice” (77). As Venice is the city that remains “implicit” for him, he must speak of it to distinguish “other cities’ qualities” (77). While Khan would wish for an exhaustive description of Venice, Polo is afraid that he would lose Venice once and for all if he speaks of it in words. He worries that in describing other cities he has incrementally lost Venice.
“Trading Cities 5”
Esmeralda is a city of water, whereby a network of canals and streets intersect each other, so one can choose to travel by land or water. The shortest distance is “not a straight line but a zigzag that ramifies in tortuous optional routes, the ways that open to each passer-by are never two, but many” (79). This means that the repetitious humdrum that ails inhabitants of other cities does not afflict Esmeralda’s citizens, who must continually traverse different routes. Those with secrets to keep and the swallows of the air have even more intricate routes. Polo considers that maps of Esmeralda should include “in different colored inks, all these routes, solid and liquid, evident and hidden” (79).
“Cities and Eyes 4”
The one-time traveler to Phyllis notices all the city’s beauties and distinguishing features. However, should he be forced to stay there all of his life, what makes the city distinctive will fade before his eyes, as he spends his days in dreary routines. There are many cities like Phyllis “which elude the gaze of all, except the man who catches them by surprise” (82).
“Cities and Names 3”
For a long time, Pyrrha was one of those cities that the traveler only knew by name. He had a mental picture of it as a fortified city on a bay. However, when he visits Pyrrha “everything I imagined was forgotten” as he familiarizes himself with its realities (83). However, the city he first associated with the name Pyrrha remains in his fantasy, and he has no name for it.
“Cities and the Dead 2”
When he reaches the city of Adelma, the traveler is confronted with likenesses of familiars who have already died. He considers that “you reach a moment in life when, among the people you have known, the dead outnumber the living. And the mind refuses to accept more faces, more expressions: on every new face you encounter, it prints the old forms, for each one finds the most suitable mask” (85). He then considers that Adelma might be the city that people who are dying travel to, and that by extension he too must be dead.
“Cities and the Sky 1”
Eudoxia has a carpet from which the city’s true form can be perceived, and “each place in the carpet corresponds to a place in the city” like a faithful reflection (86). However, the carpet also reflects the individual experiences of Eudoxia’s inhabitants. An oracle proposed that one of the objects, either the carpet or the city, reflects divine constellations and orbits. Augurers assumed the oracle referred to the carpet, but the traveler thinks that the true map might also be the city itself.
“Coda to Part 6”
Khan teases Polo that his is a journey through memory, fueled by nostalgia. Khan explains himself less in words and more through some mysterious non-verbal communication that passes between the two men as they smoke their pipes. Polo contemplates the clouds of smoke and thinks that they give way to the images of cities as they are suspended in the air. There is also the possibility that the clouds represent stasis at the end of a journey, or “the sponge swollen with vital matter that no longer flows” (88).
In this middle section, the futility of words to correspond with objects emerges as a theme. For example, the city of Olivia cannot live up to the simplicity of its name, which suggests just one face of the city. Instead, Polo’s verbal descriptions of the city, which consider the place’s many contradictions, would remove Khan from the concept of Olivia and lead him somewhere completely different. Paradoxically, instead of saying that words are unreliable, Polo concludes that “falsehood is never in words; it is in things” (53). Thus, it is as though the phenomenal world does not accurately describe the name, and the concept of a city might better align with its reality.
The idea of duality also reigns over this middle section, as the narrative moves to contemplate Polo’s native Venice, a city of canals which sees itself everywhere reflected in water. Throughout the double cities navigated, Polo brings up ideas of competing presiding deities, as well as the contest for legitimacy between the ephemeral and durable aspects of the city. He introduces the paradoxical idea that the ephemeral can be durable, especially in the city of Ersilia, where buildings are accompanied by web-like threads that denote the relationships between people. Ironically, when the city grows, it is the stone buildings that are demolished while the threads remain, ever expanding. The refugee inhabitants then leave and, taking their threads with them, build Ersilia elsewhere. Here, it is as though the ephemeral networks give the city its identity rather than the buildings. This also acts as a metaphor for Polo’s storytelling, as he transposes the features of one city onto another, carrying the vital idea on his journey.
Khan’s imperialistic instincts lead him to demand an account of Venice, Polo’s home. He feels slighted by the omission in Polo’s narrative; however, Polo assures him that he has been speaking of Venice implicitly in his descriptions of other cities. Polo fears that by talking about Venice and making its double in words, he might lose the more authentic-seeming images of the actual city and never be able to return to it in its pure form. Still, Khan grows frustrated and accuses Polo of merely collecting moods, which are entities he cannot fully possess and conquer. A deeper sense of loss is also introduced in the debut of the “Cities and the Dead” narrative thread. Appearing midway through the novel, this thread speaks to the wearying Polo’s fear that his most vital days and journeys are behind them, and all that lies ahead are reminders of the past.
By Italo Calvino
Asian History
View Collection
Books About Art
View Collection
Books & Literature
View Collection
Colonialism & Postcolonialism
View Collection
European History
View Collection
Fantasy
View Collection
Italian Studies
View Collection
Magical Realism
View Collection
National Book Awards Winners & Finalists
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection