50 pages • 1 hour read
Jennifer A. NielsenA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
A house of cards is a common metaphor to underline the fragility of an idea or institution, and Nielsen uses this to illustrate Elsa’s changing mindset about her own country over the course of the war. At the beginning of the book, the young girl explains the geopolitical tensions between European nations to Felix by constructing four houses out of playing cards, one for each of the main empires: British, Russian, German, and Austro-Hungarian. However, she makes Austria-Hungary differently than the others, commenting to Felix: “Your empire is made up of several small countries all controlled by one Kaiser. Each country has a different language and religion and culture. Worse still, all the countries hate one another” (19). When she blows on these disconnected cards, the house topples over, highlighting Austria-Hungary’s weakness.
This allegory is then repeated several times over the course of the novel, with different characters referencing houses of cards to symbolize the volatile and uncertain nature of the conflict. Dimitri, for instance, tells Elsa that Germany is “a house of cards” (260) about to fall, using her own metaphor against her. Elsa gradually becomes more doubtful of the German empire’s strength and ability to prevail in the war. Toward the novel’s end, she reflects on both of her conversations with Felix and Dimitri, and uses the metaphor again: “The winds had turned against Germany now. All that remained was to wonder how long until the last card fell” (281).
Sergeant Baum’s Golden Cross of Merit is one of the most significant pieces of symbolism in Lines of Courage. The object first appears in the story when Sergeant Baum shows it to his son, Felix:
In his hand was an old medal. It had a red cross set on a round gold background, hung from a bright red triangular cloth with a pin on the back. One edge of the cloth was torn, but otherwise it was still in perfect condition (24).
When his father offers it to him, Felix refuses it, stating that he “won’t accept what [he hasn’t] earned” (25). Over the course of the narrative, the medal is traded between all the main characters, highlighting their connections and thus echoing the novel’s title. Sergeant Baum gives it to Kara, who helped an injured enemy soldier despite her orders. She then passes it on to Juliette, who hopes to buy her father’s ransom with it. Instead, she later gives it to Dimitri to help pay for his own family’s freedom. Elsa then gets the medal back after she recognizes it as Sergeant Baum’s, so her father, Major Dressler, ends up keeping it.
At the end of the novel, when all five main characters are reunited after saving Major Dressler’s life, the latter tells them:
Medals are given to those who show exceptional courage. But do you know? Most of the people who receive them will claim they are not courageous at all. They will only say they were in a terrible situation and made the best choice they could. […] This medal belongs to every one of you. At some point, each of you found yourself in a terrible situation, and you responded with courage, with honor, and with kindness. Through your great examples, you saved me (326-27).
This reinforces the medal’s significance as a symbol of courage and resilience, which contributes to the themes of Anger Versus Empathy in Times of Conflict as well as The Intersection of Collective and Personal History.
Juliette’s red knitted hat holds personal significance, as it was given to her by her father before he was taken prisoner. It also takes on a larger symbolic meaning when she offers it to Dimitri: “She had wanted him to have the hat for warmth, but it meant so much more to him. What she had really given him was hope” (233).
Like the Golden Cross of Merit and Igor’s Red Star, Juliette’s red hat is one of the objects that travel between the main characters and connect them to one another. The hat is first mentioned when Juliette sells it to Kara, who, realizing how much it means to Juliette, gives it back to her. This symbolizes Kara’s selflessness, which is echoed by Juliette’s later gesture toward Dimitri:
She took a deep breath, then offered him her knitted hat. ‘I’ll be warm here. I think you might need this more than me.’
Last night, Juliette had told Dimitri all about her father being imprisoned by the Germans. He couldn’t accept this gift. ‘This hat was from your father.’
‘My father would want to know that I am the kind of person who helps others’ (229-30).
Later, this action is rewarded as the hat connects Juliette back to her family when her mother recognizes it on Dimitri. Finally, the young girl offers it to Major Dressler when he is injured, reinforcing the novel’s message about interconnectedness one last time.
Like the Golden Cross of Merit and Juliette’s Red Knitted Hat, Igor’s stitched red star is one of the objects that are exchanged several times between characters to highlight their connections. Igor first shows the star to Dimitri as a symbol of freedom for the Russian people. Although Dimitri is loyal to the Tsar, he is seduced by the idea and, when his friend is killed on the front, he takes his red star to send to Igor’s family. The red star then takes on a more personal meaning for him, as Dimitri dreams of being free from the war and bringing his family to France: “Igor’s symbol of freedom. Maybe it could be his symbol of freedom too” (238). Over the course of Dimitri’s journey, the narrative repeatedly emphasizes his desire for freedom and peace by referencing the red star. Eventually, the young boy offers it to Captain Garinov as a gesture of peace, commenting: “To me, this means both freedom and friendship. I have my freedom now. And I hope for you, it will mean we part as friends” (315).
By Jennifer A. Nielsen