logo

65 pages 2 hours read

Kim Johnson

This Is My America

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2020

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Effects of Incarceration on Family and Relationships

For most of the narrative, James Beaumont, patriarch of the Beaumont family, sits on death row. His wrongful arrest and incarceration looms over the entirety of the story and affects each of the family members he leaves behind. The Beaumont family’s experience of living with an incarcerated family member are representative of the innumerable lives in the real world shaped by incarceration.

Tracy narrates the story from the first-person perspective; she watches the effects of her father’s incarceration on her family. When they visit Daddy in prison, Tracy observes the rare sight of her parents together: “[Mama] lowers her head. Daddy kisses the top of it, touching along her face. It’s so intimate I want to look away. Put a wall around them so they’re alone [...] I can’t help watching, because it’s the only time I see my parents together” (127). Moments like these, small intimacies between two people who love each other and who have created a family together, become momentous when filtered through the lens of incarceration.

In his father’s absence, Jamal takes on a paternal and caretaking role in his family. He leaves daily notes for Corinne in her lunch box and decides to go to a university nearby to be available to his family. Jamal feels helpless seeing his father incarcerated and expresses how he copes with this feeling: by maintaining a sense of control by doing what he can for his family in his father’s absence. His father’s incarceration has forced him to grow up quickly, and to put his own needs and desires aside to act as the man of the house.

The author, Kim Johnson, states in the Author’s Note that Corinne, the youngest of the Beaumont children, represents “my children’s fragile innocence on the line” (392) in the face of police brutality and mass incarceration. Indeed, there is evidence of this fragility in the text: “Her voice has a heaviness to it no seven-year-old’s should have [...] That missing piece of us that keeps us down because we only see Daddy an hour on Saturday or Monday” (13). Even though Corinne was not yet born when Daddy was arrested, she carries the weight of “invisible chains” (283) as the child of an incarcerated person.

At the end of the text, after the family has been reunited and Daddy has been freed, Tracy reflects: “It’s all real. We can let it out. We’re holding on to each other, windows rolled down, letting the wind whip on us as Daddy drives us home” (387). Their lives have been torn apart for seven long years, but they drive away from the courthouse, once again intact. This resolution is a happy one, but the narrative ends before the realities and struggles of life post-incarceration set in for the Beaumonts.

Importantly, the novel does not shy away from the lingering effects of incarceration on released individuals and their families. Tracy’s best friend, Tasha, also has a formerly incarcerated father who struggles with his adjustment to a life outside of incarceration. As a result, Tasha struggles to trust him, and resents him for his incarceration and struggles to adjust. In the Author’s Note, Johnson states that “I want to leave my readers with hope but nevertheless reflect real-life struggles, which is why Tracy’s friend Tasha and her family are still on an uphill journey of life after prison at the end of the novel” (394). The novel is realistic about the prejudice and bias that society holds against formerly incarcerated individuals, and how incarceration shapes lives during and after incarceration.

The Effects of Systemic and Interpersonal Racism on Justice

Racism exists on both a systemic and interpersonal level, which is a core idea in This Is My America. James Beaumont’s wrongful conviction is the central example in the text of how systemic and interpersonal racism affect justice. The Beaumonts are aware of the bias that played a major role in Daddy’s conviction, on the part of not only the police, but the surrounding community as well. Racism and the ways it operates on macro and microcosmic levels are central to the events of the text and have far-reaching implications for the Beaumont’s community.

Tracy recalls the death of Mr. Ridges at the hands of police, a shooting that left Quincy with a life-long injury, as well. She states, “After he was dead, it was easy to put blame on Mr. Ridges. They needed him to be guilty. Especially when they could’ve killed Quincy” (34). After police murdered Mr. Ridges, it was necessary for the police to frame his guilt even further, not to incur judgment or pushback for an innocent man’s death. The community was eager to find the Black men guilty. This is an example of both systemic and interpersonal racism that cost Mr. Ridges his life and ensured a guilty verdict for James Beaumont. Tracy articulates the effects of this interpersonal racism on her father’s trial:

I used to ask Daddy if he thought things would be different if he’d had a Black attorney, that maybe his attorney would have understood the bias in the trial more [...] It wasn’t about the race of his attorney, but about being a Black man on trial in a town that never accepted us. Everyone wanted an answer to a heinous crime, and it was easier to think it was an outsider—someone ‘not like them’ (90).

The Beaumonts were isolated from their community because they moved to Texas from New Orleans and for their race as well. As the roots of white supremacy and racism in the Beaumont’s community surface throughout the text, Tracy’s understanding comes into clearer focus. Beyond the systemic racism that incarcerates Black people at disproportionate rates, interpersonal bias plays a role as well in delaying or preventing justice because it was easier to believe that two Black men would be involved in a murder than the actual perpetrator—Richard Brighton.

Mrs. Evans’s confession implicates Richard Brighton as the murderer of Cathy and Mark Davidson. Years after the fact, she reports Brighton’s abuse against his ex-wife: “Cathy was scared because Richard kept threatening Mark, telling him not to work with James or Jackson” (368). Brighton’s anger towards the Davidsons for working with Black men was racially motivated, and the cover-up of Brighton’s crime by police implies systemic racism as well.

Racism on both a systemic and personal level does not cease to exist at the end of the text. James Beaumont’s exoneration does not fix or end racism. Although the Beaumonts achieve justice, the text leaves a lingering reminder that for many, like the Ridges family, the harm caused by systemic and interpersonal racism are irreversible.

The Generational Cycle of Racism in America

The characters in This Is My America illustrate how prejudice, bias, and racism are embedded in American society and are linked to generational cycles. The novel uses families like the Beaumonts and Ridges, Black families living through the harmful effects of police brutality, racism, and incarceration, and the Evanses, a white family with ties to the Ku Klux Klan to illustrate how these cycles continue to harm communities of color disproportionately.

Jamal represents how harmful and oppressive systems disproportionately place blame on Black people. Despite his prolific success as a track star and his promising future at Baylor University, society quickly casts Jamal as a murderer and a thug when Angela is murdered. For much of the narrative, Jamal must live in hiding for fear that he will be thrown into the same carceral system that was built to re-enslave freed Black people generations ago. When Tracy and Jamal are reunited, Jamal gives an impassioned speech that lays out his reasons for not going to the police in the aftermath of Angela’s murder: “The laws might change, the system might look different [...] Four hundred years, and we still ain’t American to them” (297-298). Jamal’s reticence to turn himself over to a system he knows was not designed to protect him represents the ancestral trauma that the descendants of enslaved people carry with them in America.

With this generational trauma comes generational strength. In times of strife or hardship, Tracy often calls on the strength of her ancestors. When Innocence X takes on the case, Tracy’s response is to feel “My ancestors’ strength pouring into me, fully armored so I can fight to prove their innocence” (197). Tracy understands that the cycle exists, but that individuals working together possess the power to disrupt this cycle. At the community meeting, she appeals to her community that racist beliefs convicted her father and that “Now that generational curse is passing down to my brother. The son…the son of a ‘killer’ must be a killer” (309). She goes on to say this cycle can be broken and the community has the power to stop it.

The cycle of racism also affects the Ridges family, and they represent the innumerable families whose lives have been torn apart by police brutality. Police murdered Jackson Ridges, the patriarch of the family, when he resisted the false charges made against him. In response to this, his daughter Beverly becomes a cop to try to change the system from within. Although she struggles throughout the novel with her commitment to her family and her commitment to her job to protect and serve, Beverly proves herself when she is shot. Though the book is largely critical of the criminal justice system and the police as an institution, Beverly represents a small beacon of hope that suggests the system may not be entirely broken or irreparable.

The Black families in this text fight against unjust systems that incarcerate and kill their family members. The Evanses, a white family, prove that those with the societal power and influence to create change perpetuate this cycle of racism over generations. Dean represents this when he confesses his worry about the effects of his mother’s beliefs: “What if I’m as bad as her? [...] That everything she’s raised me around is so ingrained in me I won’t even know, and then I do something to mess us up?” (216). Dean goes on to reveal that he has ingrained racial biases when he says that he initially believed Jamal was guilty. Dean’s admission harms Tracy and his bias has real consequences for their friendship. This illustrates how ingrained beliefs can have a harmful impact even when intentions are good.

Of the white characters, Mrs. Evans proves just how dangerous the cycle of generational racism can be. Mrs. Evans learned her racist beliefs from the community, including her father, who was a Grand Wizard in the Galveston County chapter of the KKK. Although a part of her understood that the lynching of Vietnamese man Minh Nguyen was wrong, when it came to speaking out against Richard Brighton for the murders of Mark and Cathy Davidson, she centered her own safety and well-being. Her internalized bias and racism convinced her that James Beaumont and Jackson Ridges were guilty even though she knew the truth: “Things were settled. James had a trial. They found him guilty [...] My God. What did I do?” (369). During her confession, Mrs. Evans realizes the gravity of her inaction, and its consequences on the lives of two families. Tracy puts this realization into focus: “My father didn’t do anything wrong, and Jackson Ridges paid with his life” (370). Mrs. Evans’s passivity, linked to the racist beliefs she inherited from her father and a willingness to trust in a corrupt criminal justice system, wreaked immeasurable havoc and pain on the lives of those in her community.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text